From: ephemeral@ephemeralfic.org Date: 12 Apr 2001 12:59:22 -0000 Subject: FALTER by Innisfree Source: direct Reply To: milagro73@excite.com TITLE: Falter AUTHOR: Innisfree E-MAIL: milagro73@excite.com CLASSIFICATION: MSR, A SUMMARY: "Things aren't right with us." This is a bit dark and the gloves are off, but hang in there. RATING: R (language) SPOILERS: Three Words. ARCHIVE: Yes -- just e-mail me. DISCLAIMERS: They're not mine and I'm making no money. I think we all know who they belong to, unless somebody out there spent the 90s living under a rock. If you have nothing better to do than go after the fans, just remember that karma can be very unkind. __________________________________________ In the dead of night, her car rolls up to the curb in front of 42 Hegel Place and slows to a stop. He shoots only the most cursory of looks in her direction before he pops open the passenger door and slides out, one formerly dead foot following the other. He is leaning down to offer her of his newly chilly goodbyes when the sound of the engine cutting off stops him cold. "Scully?" She pulls the key from the ignition and pulls herself from the vehicle with whatever remaining grace she can muster in the last trimester of her pregnancy. The driver's side door slams and its echo moves across a sleepy street. "Scully, what are you doing? I thought we agreed that I can handle myself in my own apartment without you looking over my shoulder every five minutes." There is neither warmth nor humor in the tone of his voice. A passerby might think he sounds angry or annoyed, but to her, he simply sounds... empty. Her hands come up to rest on the top of the car, but she is not resting. She looks like she is steadying herself, or perhaps holding herself back. "We? WE didn't agree on anything, Mulder. WE haven't agreed on much since you've been back. And WE are going upstairs now." He looks at her, confused by this sudden assertiveness. She has done nothing but tiptoe around him since he woke to find her crying over him in the hospital less than two weeks ago. He is having trouble finding his bearings in this new breakable world where he has risen from the dead. This world where his suddenly fragile partner looks at him as if he is the most fragile thing of all. "I can't tell you what to do, Scully," he says tiredly. "Never could." "Never stopped you from trying before." "Well, all I'm interested in doing right now is going to bed and dreaming about what kind of damage I'm going to do to Doggett's face the next time I see him. Give him something to go along with that little gash he picked up getting Absalom killed." He holds her gaze just long enough to see the way her face falls again, anger fading away into sadness. Somewhere in the back of his mind, he wonders why his own anger doesn't fade like that anymore. *** "Just take the bed for Christ's sake, Scully. I slept on this couch for seven years. I can sleep on it tonight." Leather meets leather as he tosses his jacket on the arm of the couch and sits down to pull off his boots. Looking down at his feet, he listens for the sound of her moving into the bedroom. All he hears is the gurgle of a fish tank where one less fish darts around in the water's green glow. "You're not gonna fit on this couch, Scully. So if you're planning on staying the night, you'd better take the bed." He lifts his head to find her standing perfectly still by the television. She appears to him like a statue, every muscle that is visible in the dim light rigid and still. There is a glint in her eye, but he can't be sure if it's just a reflection, or if it's something more. "They almost killed you tonight." Her voice is controlled and steady, so low that it would be a whisper if she dropped it down a notch and a rumble if she lifted it one. The trembling she feels in her stomach at the thought of him dying again infuses her words with just the barest hint of fear. "Don't start this, Scully." She ignores him, continuing to speak as if he had said nothing at all. She has finally found purpose, and she will not be deterred. "I've been doing a lot of waiting for the past six months, Mulder. Waiting for you to come back. Waiting for some clue how to find you. Waiting for the pain to go away when I buried you. And for two weeks, I've been waiting for you to talk to me. Waiting for you to ask me." Her voice takes on a sharp edge. "I'm all done with waiting." He sighs and tosses a boot away in the direction of his desk. "What do you want me to say, Scully? Why don't you tell me, and then I'll say it, and we can both go to sleep. It's three in the fucking morning." Every time he speaks, he is certain that he sees her head jerk back ever so slightly. As if she has been hit. But every time her head jerks back, it seems to come a little farther forward on the return. This time her whole body moves forward, and he finds her sitting next to him on his couch. And this time, he is the one who jerks back, reclaiming some of the previous distance between their two bodies. She decides she'll try the sensitive approach one more time before she lets him have it. "I want you to tell me what you're really feeling," she says kindly. "I want you to know that you can tell me what happened to you... if you want to. I want you to stop talking to me like I'm some stranger who picked you up in the ICU." The hard look on his face tells her that the sensitive approach has failed yet again. So be it, she thinks. She's not going to let him walk away from it this time. "But since you're not going to do any of those things, I want you to listen." "Dammit, Scully..." "Listen." Her voice slices into him as sharply as anything they used to cut him on that ship that still haunts him in dreams. "Listen to me now," she says more softly, "and then I'll leave if you want me to." She is choosing her words carefully, trying to tamp down on the anger that rises up in her to suggest other words. Words like "leave and never come back." Words like "let you get yourself killed any time you want to." She stops them before they leave her mouth not only because they are cruel, but because she knows that she could never keep the promises implied in such threats. His only response is silence, and she takes it as a sign that she can continue without further resistance from him. "Just listen..." The words fall out of her mouth in a whisper as she exhales, dying away as such words do when a particular argument is over and the only thing left to add is some small closing punctuation. He looks at her, tilting his head slightly. She thinks that his face would have once looked amused, or irritated, or intrigued if she had demanded silence from him. But she never did. Not this way. And now, as he waits for her to speak, she finds a face so blank that she briefly considers checking his pulse. She takes a deep breath. They never talked like this before. They never really needed to. Or maybe they did, and it has only become clear to her now. "Things aren't right with us." She pauses, waiting for him to argue with her, to tell her that she's imagining things. She is not really shocked when he says nothing, but she is disappointed nonetheless. The man she knew would have sooner worn a pink tutu to work than pass up an argument. If she can just draw him into this conversation, no matter how hostile he becomes, she thinks she'll have some hope of making things right between them again. "I don't know why, but I can imagine why. I think that you're angry with me. I'm not even sure you know it, but I think you are." He shifts uncomfortably against the leather backing of the couch and fixes her with a glare that seems to bore right into her. "If I were angry, I'd know it. And you'd know it. Believe me." "Fine. Are you?" "You're asking me if I'm angry." "If you know, then you know. So are you?" "Maybe," he tells her with a challenge in his voice. A pause. "Yes," he taunts before he thinks better of it. "I don't know!" he finishes with irritation as he pulls his knees up to his chest. She lifts her hand to push an errant strand of hair behind her ear. Out of the corner of her eye, she thinks she sees his hand lift half an inch from where it rests on the back of the couch. A phantom unconscious gesture that mimics her own and recalls all the times that he performed the same act. Before. "Well, I know. I hear it in your voice. You're angry that I didn't find you. That I didn't save you from what happened. I wasn't even the one to pull you from the ground. You think I looked but I didn't look hard enough. You come home, and I have a partner and a baby on the way, and you think my life went right along without you in it. Like your disappearance was just some unpleasant blip on my radar." He finds it unnerving to hear her giving voice to his thoughts... the thoughts he has been unwilling or unable to admit thinking. They are his thoughts, goddammit. HIS. And yet nothing is his anymore. He is still naked, still splayed out in some chair where anyone can come and take whatever they want from him. On the ship, they took his flesh and his dignity. Now, she takes his thoughts. "You said it. I didn't." "But you thought it, Mulder." "Was there some inaccuracy in what you just said? Sounded like a fairly good summary of recent events to me." She bites her lip to keep from crying or yelling, she's not sure which. She doesn't know if she can do this. She isn't sure what to do with his anger, and she has no idea what to do with her own. He isn't the only one who feels betrayed by a partner and a friend. "Almost everything I said was true," she says deliberately. Her tone is cautious and restrained, but neither of them can miss the edge that runs with it. "I didn't save you, or find you, or pull you from the ground. I have had a partner. I am going to have a baby. But you misunderstand the context of all of these things. I told you that I'm not sure you can ever know what it was like for me these past months. Well," she offers with a conciliatory note in her voice, "I guess it's rather hard for you to try if I don't tell you how it felt." "Who are you and what have you done with my partner?" His words cause the edges of her mouth to pull outward and form an awkward, involuntary smile. It fades as quickly as it came when she realizes that there is no laughter in his voice. "I had a lot of time to think about all the things I never said to you. I can't tell you how many times I begged God to let me see you again just so that I wouldn't have to carry those words around inside me for the rest of my life. This would appear to be the moment where I fulfill my part of that bargain. It's the new and improved me.' Mulder snorts loudly in response. "Don't like it? Tough. I'm sick of being fine. I've been anything but fine since the moment I got the call from the Gunmen telling me you were gone. Do you know where I was when I got that call, Mulder?" "I don't know. Interviewing donors with higher sperm motility than I had?" A moment ago, she wasn't sure that she could do this. Now she thinks she can do this but doubts she'll be able to get through it without hitting him. "Maybe being tortured and left for dead gives you the right to act like an asshole, Mulder. But you're going to feel like an asshole shortly." She has piqued his interest. He leans forward and musters a small sneer that might have been a smile if he didn't hate himself so much for talking to her this way. "I've felt like an asshole since I was twelve. So I wouldn't expect too much." "You think I went back to the fertility clinic to try again, huh? That makes perfect sense, Mulder. I can see why you would immediately jump to the conclusion that the first thing I did after finding out my partner had been abducted by aliens was run off to try in vitro fertilization again with some anonymous donor. I can see why you would assume that I was just buttering you up when I told you that you were the only man whose child I could imagine carrying. Perfectly understandable." She is secretly pleased to see that she was right. A look of uncertainty appears on Mulder's face. His sneer has fled the stage and been replaced by a lopsided frown of confusion. "What do you mean? You mean you went back to the fertility clinic before I left for Bellefleur?" "Yes, that's what I meant, Mulder." She rolls her eyes, sarcasm still dripping from her words as they register on his face. "It's your baby, Mulder," she says pointedly. In her mind, she adds the word "dumbass" to the end of her announcement. Might have been appropriate to say it, she thinks, since he is presently looking at her with a dumb look worthy of their new president's worst day in front of a camera. "It's our baby, Mulder. I guess you were right about not giving up on a miracle." She fidgets with her hands, looking at them with forced fascination as her fingers play with one another. She is waiting to hear something that will convince her telling him this news was not an enormous error in judgment. "How can you be sure?" he asks carefully. Not quite the tears of joy for which she had been hoping. Vampires he takes on faith. Normal human reproduction needs to be tediously picked apart with the fine-toothed comb of a skeptic. "It was a fairly easy process of elimination, Mulder. You are the only man I was sleeping with at the time." From the way he has been acting with her, she isn't even certain that he remembers how close they had become in the months prior to his disappearance. She remembers. She even thinks she knows the night this baby was conceived. God help the poor child. She is fairly sure his little life began in Los Angeles. He does remember. He has pushed the memories away in the two weeks since he returned to find her inexplicably pregnant, but they come flooding back to him now. Visual memories of their bodies wrapped together in every position he had ever imagined and a few he had never known. Tactile memories of soft skin, and damp skin, and skin that was so warm to the touch he had thought it might burn him. Auditory memories of her voice calling his name, sometimes passionately, sometimes softly, sometimes with what sounded like love. For years, he had thought that if he could only have one night in Scully's arms, one night inside her body, he could die happy and fulfilled. How could he have known that no number of nights with her would be enough to send him to his grave content? "I remember, Scully," he sighs. "I remember. But like I said, how can you sure? Maybe they didn't even have to take you. You went along with CGB Spender without even a hint of a threat and you lost most of a night. He could have done anything to you." She feels the tears beginning to well in her eyes. As easily as she cries in these days where hormones and resurrected lovers rear their heads, she is fairly sure she could have kept herself together if he had not raised the specter of a dead man who said he only wanted to do something good for the world before he died. For months, she has wondered about those missing hours. Wondered about waking up in a strange bed with satin pajamas and no memory of the night before. The truth is, she doesn't know that something wasn't done to her during that missing time. The only thing she knows with absolute medical certainty is that Fox Mulder is the father of the child she is carrying. And at some point, that detail became the only one that mattered to her. "This child is yours, Mulder. I believe it was conceived naturally. I understand there is always a possibility that it was not. But I am the biological mother of this baby, and you are the biological father." He is surprised to hear the coldness in her voice as she tells him one more time that he is about to have a son or daughter. He can't blame her. Cold is the word that best describes how he has been treating her. He has been so cold because cold is all he could feel. Perhaps it is a side effect of three months buried in hard ground beneath the unseasonable Raleigh snow. He had been thinking that this chill inside him was simply something he would have to live with. But hearing that same chill in her voice makes him desperate to be warm again. "Scully... I'm happy for you..." "I already heard that speech, Mulder. If you'd leave off those last two words, I might actually feel happy for myself." He bows his head. Guilty. He knows he should be happy not just for her, but for both of them. He finds it hard to be happy for anyone when he has no idea what any of this means. No idea where he stands with her. No idea what kind of life he has returned to find in this place that seems familiar and strange all at once. "I'm just confused, Scully. I don't know what to make of everything that's happened. I feel like I did when I walked into the theater to see Aliens an hour after it started. I recognized Sigourney Weaver, and I recognized that universe they were in, but I had no idea what the hell was going on. Last time I saw her she'd been cuddled up with a cat in a deep sleep chamber. Suddenly she's running around with Michael Biehn and a kid." In spite of her best efforts to quash it, a laugh catches Scully off guard and escapes her. Mulder looks over at her, a small smile lighting up his face. She thinks it might be the first real smile she's seen on him since he waved to her from a jetway leading to a plane bound for Oregon. "I see," she says quietly, the smile slowly disappearing. "And now you're walking in on me running around with Doggett and a new line of maternity wear." "Something like that." "Agent Doggett was picked to lead the taskforce investigating your disappearance. Skinner and I were interviewed, catalogued, and generally treated like suspects. Doggett had half the world convinced that you had staged the whole thing and were really running around the Hoover building stealing files." "I don't know why I'm surprised. Someone could put a bullet in my head in front of the Director himself and they'd find a way to make it my fault." Mulder rises and ambles over to his fish tank, lifts the lid and offers a late night flake snack to the fish who managed to survive his absence. He thinks they deserve a little bonus for hanging in there for him. He thinks the discovery of an empty fish tank to mirror the emptiness inside him might have pushed him right over the edge. "I wasn't surprised by that. On the other hand, the things Agent Doggett told me about you came as a complete surprise." Mulder looks over toward the couch to find Scully looking back at him, expectantly. "He told you about my condition." "That's a nice way of putting it, Mulder," she says as if she is giving him the most insincere compliment. "He told me you knew you were dying for a year. Which was... as you know... news to me." Mulder looks back at the fish. Watches them as they swim up to the surface to wrap little lips around big flakes and then dart away with their prizes. Fish are like zombies, he thinks. They eat, drink, and make love before they die. If they're dying, they don't know. They just continue swimming around in their gallon of water, carrying out their fish activities until one day, the other fish find them floating at the top of the tank. Would she understand what he means if he told her that last year he was trying to be a fish? "I'm sorry about that, Scully." He shrugs his shoulders rather lamely. He can think of nothing else to say. "Uh-huh. Well, it would seem that one way or another I was destined to stand next to your coffin this year." He walks back toward her and sits again, closer to her this time than before. He no longer feels the need to be surrounded by the corner where the back of the couch meets the arm. He thinks he has spent enough time apart from her to last him for quite a while. "At least this version of Choose Your Own Funeral has you around at the end to apologize." The accusation that lies within her words is unmistakable. "There was nothing to be done about it. I didn't want to spend the last year of my life feeling sad and watching you wait for me to die." Tentatively, he reaches his hand out to touch her arm where it rests on her stomach, stroking it softly. It is another apology, and it is a peace offering. No wonder he is shocked when the arm he is caressing lifts off the couch and makes hard contact with his shoulder. "You! You, you, you! You fucking coward, Mulder! What about me? How do you think I would have felt? How do you think I did feel hearing from Special Agent John Doggett what I should have heard from you?" Her hand, now a fist, continues to pound against his shoulder. She is not hurting him. He has recently redefined his notion of pain. In some strange way which seems to fit the two of them perfectly, she is connecting with him. He wants to feel something and this is something. He feels her, and what he feels is real. "How could you lie to me, Mulder? How could you agree to father a child you knew... you KNEW you would never see? How could you tell me you loved me, and let me love you, and never tell me you were dying?!" The fist beats against his shoulder with a discernible rhythm now, but it loses force with every stroke. She is tiring. The anger is flowing out of her and away. He is somewhat surprised to find that it does not take up new residence inside him even though it seems directed at him. It passes through him, and like her, he lets it go. "You were dead, Mulder," she whimpers, any clear train of thought disappearing in the darkness as her hand stops moving and latches onto his shoulder like a death grip. "You were so cold... what they did to you... I was too late... I lost you, and I lost Jeremiah... they put you in the ground... I wanted to die, Mulder. I wanted to die." Exhausted, her head falls against the shoulder her hand had been assaulting. "Sssshhhhh... Scully, it's alright. I'm here. Ssssshhhh. I'm alive." He whispers the words against her ear as he feels a wetness soaking through his shirt where her eyes are resting. He had forgotten what it felt like to give comfort just as surely as he had forgotten what it felt like to receive it. "And then two weeks... two weeks alive, and you're running off like you have some kind of death wish," she says brokenly as she lifts her head from his shoulder to look him straight in the eye. "Well, I'm not burying you again, Mulder," she tells him in a choked voice that fights to make its point without breaking. "I'm not standing by your coffin to collect another flag. The next time they bury you, they can bury me right next to you." "Don't say that, Scully." "I will say it," she tells him with faint fire in her sad eyes. "It's true. You think about that the next time you want to play games with fate the way you did tonight. My role as grieving widow was a one-time performance with no return engagements." She was right. He will never really know what she has been through in these horrible months, just as she will never truly know what he went through, separated from her, body and spirit broken into pieces only to be reassembled around a Lazarus heart. But he understands much more than he did. He understands that she is not the same woman he left behind in the supposed safety of D.C. while he chased after lights in the night sky. In her own way, she too has been broken down and rebuilt into something that is simultaneously stronger and more vulnerable. The woman he last saw six months ago had always been afraid of needing him too much. This woman seems to have learned that fear alone does not stop need. This woman seems to have lost her interest in pretending. It's almost overwhelming to return and find that she needs him as much as he once admitted to needing her. As much as he needs her now. "You weren't really a widow, Scully," he tells her with a soft lilt in his voice, letting his hand brush her hair behind her ear as it had ached to do earlier. "Please," she sniffs. "I had everything but the ring and the tax returns. I felt like one. Everyone treated me like one." "Always a widow, never a bride, Scully?" he asks her, his voice filled with the gentle humor she missed terribly during this long cold season. A fist connects with his shoulder once again. He yelps for effect, but she knows that they have finally brought each other back to the borders of a world once so familiar. A world where he makes affectionate jokes at her expense and she pretends to be offended... pretends that she doesn't love being the only one he cares about enough to tease. "I'm sorry, Scully. For everything. For both of us. We didn't deserve this, you and I." She traces a finger down the side of his face where fading red scars still mark him. It moves slowly, carefully, lingering briefly over the cleft in his chin she has always loved before it rises to trace the fullness of his lips. "No. But this. Here. Now. This we deserve, Mulder." She presses her lips to his, cautiously at first, then confidently when she feels him moving beneath her. She runs her tongue lightly over the outside of his mouth before slipping it inside to take the smallest taste of what she has missed. It is an act of worship, but to him it feels like the touch of someone who is afraid the slightest pressure will cause him to shatter and disappear. He feels her begin to pull away and crushes her to him with a kiss that is forceful. Possessive. Defiant. A kiss that says she belongs to him, and he belongs to her. And let no man tear asunder. She is breathless when he finally breaks the lock he has on her mouth, and he is more than a little pleased that he can, in fact, still take her breath away. Not at all bad for a forty-something guy only recently returned to the land of the living. "Better be careful there, stud. I'm breathing for two now." She smiles at him. A full smile that hides nothing, that is not even conscious of itself. A smile that is joy in its purest visible form. And he laughs. A real laugh, one that sounds through his whole body and emerges unguarded. This is happiness, he thinks. Whatever we can know of it. "So. Mulder." She takes a firm tone, doing her best to appear serious even as her hands slide beneath his sweater just above his belt and undermine her own charade. "Hmmmmm?" He finds himself distracted by her beauty. Mesmerized by the moonlight that seems to dance all over her body. "I told you that if you listened, I'd leave if you wanted me to." Her words snap him back to full attention. She is not really serious, he knows. Her eyes reach out to him playfully even as she holds her face in a grim mask. But he feels serious in this moment. He feels --- he realizes with amazement --- so many things suddenly, where an hour ago he would have been relieved to feel anything, one thing, ever again. "I don't want you to leave, Scully," he tells her quietly. "Not tonight." She looks at him quizzically, uncertain whether she is understanding the meaning of his words. "But some other time... you'll want me to leave." She is not sure why she phrases her question as a statement. Perhaps because a question carries the sound of hope. She is afraid to hope for too much. "I don't think I could ever want you to leave, Scully. But I know that we still have things to work out. It's been a long time. We have to get used to each other again. And maybe we'll both need space for that." Her worn-out heart falls a few inches inside her. His words, while true, remind her that their new world is not a perfect one. It is actually much like the old one. Full of misunderstandings, and wounded pride, and so much fear. But that old world was also once filled with love, and trust, and laughter, and a faith that two imperfect people make something more perfect together. And the thought that new worlds can be like old worlds fills her with hope to make her heart rise again. "There'll be time for all of that," she tells him. "But not tonight." "Not tonight," he repeats in a whisper as he brushes his lips against her cheek. "Now tell me you're not planning on sleeping on this couch, Mulder." He grins and takes her hand. "I am getting kind of old to be sleeping on this couch. Probably wake up in the morning with a back as stiff as a rod." Her hand in his, she tries with some difficulty to stand and bring him up with her. Her balance falters, and he rises easily at just that moment, his hand shooting out instinctively to brace itself against the small of her back. He restores some tiny bit of grace to the moment without making her feel that she is anything less than grace in motion. Falter. Recover. Falter. Recover. It has always been their way. "Well, as you so tactfully pointed out, I can't fit on it very well at the moment. So if I'm staying," she breathes against him, long fingers traveling suggestively across his chest, "I guess we'll both have to make due with your bed." They walk toward a room that once held only boxes of memories and things forgotten and now spills light out through its doorframe. Hand in hand. No hurry. No rush. "This might be tough, Scully," he laughs. "I may have reverted to being the cover hog from hell. Been a while since I've shared a bed with someone." She stops at the threshold just at the edge of the soft light and stares up at him, tears threatening in her eyes again before she bows her head and lays it against his broad chest. "It's been a while for me too, Mulder. But then I never really got used to sleeping alone." Her arms wrap around him and she brings him as close to her as he can be with an unborn child sheltered between them. "I think we'll remember, Scully. Things are different. I know." He holds her and offers a silent prayer to her God, the God in whom he swears he does not believe. It is an unusual prayer, so like the proud man who makes it. A prayer not of asking, but of gruff thanks for having turned away from reading the box scores long enough to watch over her, and this new life, while he was gone. "But I think," he whispers as he moves them beyond the threshold and into the light. "Some things... some things remain the same." END Author's Notes: I'll refrain from commenting on Three Words. I hope this story speaks for me. Five more episodes, Chris. Five more episodes. Let's cowboy up over there, how about it?