From: ephemeral@ephemeralfic.org Date: 28 Jan 2002 18:10:23 -0000 Subject: The Park by C and Me Source: direct Reply To: berngard3@yahoo.com The Park by C and Me berngard3@yahoo.com Date Authored: 8/21/01 Classification: R, V Keywords: MSR Summary: A little conversation Spoilers: 6th Season, and maybe S7, well before William was a glint in someone's eye. Disclaimer: All characters belong to Chris Carter, 1013 Productions and Fox Network, even if infringement were ever intended Archive: Anywhere you please, just let me know * * * They drove in silence in the right center lane down Interstate 95, under the glow of the orange streetlights which lined the highway, passing and being passed by the thick stream of after-Thanksgiving-dinner traffic headed to D.C. Her arm was balanced on the little ledge at the bottom of the window where it met the faux leather of the door frame, her head massaged by thumb and middle finger as she leaned into her hand. Scully's gaze was trapped beyond the roadway's edge, beyond the jersey wall into the oblivion of night. It always amazed him that although this stretch of road passed directly through suburbia which joined the two large cities of Baltimore and Washington, beyond the highway all was black and lifeless. No streetlights. No roads. No houses leaking the glow of lamps in the front window. Just ... black. Nothingness. And in the light of day, trees. Unending forest. Or so it seemed. Mulder's gaze remained focused on the ribbon of broken lane lines and red tail lights of the vehicles in front of him, his features ghostly green in the glow of the instrument panel. Thanksgiving dinner at the Scullys had been everything and nothing like Mulder imagined. House full of squealing munchkin children knee-high and running full tilt after each other with rubber swords held high, bath towels pinned to their necks like capes. Bill and Tara and Charlie and Sally and Maggie ... and children. All smiles and cheer. The house decked for the advancing Advent and Christmas seasons. Scully in her element ... or so he had thought. But she wasn't. And because of that, neither was he. His partner had remained moody and distant throughout the afternoon and evening. Polite but quiet and sullen. Responsive to questions but not engaging in conversation. Not even with her mother. Mulder, on the other hand, had bantered and laughed and socialized. He even tried to flirt a little with Scully, something up to this night both unaccomplished and unsuccessful in the extreme. Maggie had been her usual bright and welcoming self, ever watchful of her guests' needs, ever ... mindful of her guest's past. Mulder wondered for the millionth time if she remembered Melissa's death every time she looked at him. For that matter, did his presence recall pictures of Scully's abduction and deathbed return, her cancer, Emily, the frost burns she sported after their sojourn to Antarctica? Or did he just remind his partner's mother that once Scully laughed and giggled, not so long before she met Fox Mulder? Suddenly, as the green and white sign for the Route 100 exit loomed above them on the metal crossbrace, Mulder switched lanes to the right and signaled his exit. "Mulder!" Scully braced icily from her seat next to him, grabbing at the internal handle to steady herself. "Where are you going?" "Away," was all he responded, his face tightening into hard lines of determination. " 'Away' where?" Her voice was becoming shrill, an unmistakable indication of Scully's dissent. "Away this way," Mulder replied as he reached the top of the ramp and turned the car east into the dark night. Scully could portend what was occurring. Mulder the Ever Petulant was taking an unnecessary tangent, an attempt to force her to listen and respond. "Mulder, put the car back on the highway and let's go home," she ordered sternly, straightening in her seat. "No." Scully whipped her head in his direction, taking in the set of his jaw, the steel of his forward gaze. "Mulder," she repeated, a little more definitively, a lot more angry. "Turn the car around and put us back on the highway. I don't want to do this now." No response. "Mulder," she growled, crossing her arms tightly across her chest. In the silence of the car, Mulder could hear Scully's rough and angry breathing. "No." Same unwavering determination, same clench of his jaw. "Mulder. Now." Scully hissed, her ire and voice rising as the car sped into the night farther and farther away from the interstate. He ignored her, until out of the corner of his eye he saw her shoulder slump in defeat as the anger gave way to a weary tension. "We're going to talk," Mulder directed quietly, firmly. "We don't need to talk." She ground the words at the windshield, clipped and certain. "We have nothing about which we need to talk," Scully noted succinctly through gritted teeth, her own jaw locking into characteristic stubbornness. "There is nothing wrong, Mulder." "We need to talk," he reiterated, his voice soft, the pain unmistakable to his partner, the rigidity of his determination unwavering. Scully huffed a sigh and fixed a stare out her window, her hands twisting in her lap. Only then did Mulder chance a glance in her direction, noting the indignation in the set of her posture, the worry in the movement of her fingers as they clenched and released her coat. He kept a steady speed, turning with the road, traveling further into the darkness of a night punctuated only by the vehicle's headlights, the pavement becoming ever more narrow, the slope of the hills less steep. Signs of civilization became rare, evened out until they disappeared altogether. At first the couple passed a housing development off to their left, townhouses on the right. A corner drug store and gas station. A small market, closed for the holiday, next to a darkened diner announcing "Eats", the lights of both establishments extinguished, their neon signs turned off. A deserted intersection with traffic lights. A country church and accompanying graveyard, silent and black in the night. Then ... nothing. The road ended at a park, picnic tables forlorn and remotely spaced among the few trees. In the fan of the headlights, Mulder could see a small beach, water lapping its sand the twenty feet it was wide, maybe forty feet long if you could stretch it. Mulder switched off the car and the lights, plunging them into darkness. He and Scully sat silently in the night among bare tall oaks and maples, the green grass of the park now black with the hour and season, the silver slip of beach before them. He blinked slowly, trying to imagine what he could say, where he could start, what would draw her out to explain the uncomfortable evening and growing tension between them. "What ... ," he started hesitantly, his voice hushed by the lump in his throat. "What did I do? What did I do, Scully, to ... to make you ... like this? Like ... like...." Like what? Mulder wracked his brain. 'Like you hate me,' sprang immediately to the fore, but even the most juvenile part of him could not bring himself to enunciate such a conclusion, much less truly believe it. Scully stared straight ahead, also lost in a search for words which would at least not harm even if they could not heal. There it was again, Mulder's overwhelming ability to fault himself with the emotions, the actions of others. What *had* he done, if anything? Been kind enough to accompany her tonight to a family event which in the past had been tedious at best, downright painful at its worst. Charmed her mother and sisters-in-law. Prattled sports with her brothers, even with the sullen Bill who seemed this year on better behavior than ever where her partner was concerned. Maybe Bill finally -- reluctantly to be sure -reconciled himself to Mulder as a fact of Scully's life. Maybe not. Maybe Maggie had put her foot down this time before Scully and the man of the hour appeared. Mulder had played on the floor with her nephews, allowed them to chase him down the street when he caught the football, let them tackle him on the sofa in a tickle fest. Laughed. He had laughed and enjoyed himself, and she had locked away all those pleasantries and struggled to retain some semblance of her formal, stoic, FBI persona. Scully had fumed all the while silently because he insisted on joining her today. Crashing her party, even if she wasn't in a party mood. Forcing his way into her personal life, as if he had not performed that little dance step for the last six ... seven years. She didn't need a moody, petulant partner in her life. Then neither did he, she mused, forgiving him his good grace to care. "Nothing," Scully responded quietly into the rapidly chilling air of the car. "You did nothing. It wasn't about you." She lied. "The *hell* it wasn't!" Mulder exploded as he quickly unlatched his seatbelt and scrambled out of the vehicle, slamming the door in his wake. 'The hell it was,' she remonstrated herself silently. 'It was all about you ... all and forever ... about you.' Slowly Scully extricated herself from the car and followed him across the grass, joining him as he stood before the sand. "What do you want from me, Mulder?" She grimaced at the whine in her voice. Mulder turned to her -- *on* her, she mentally corrected -- his eyes large. Even on a night with low clouds, no moon or light, she knew he was startled by the question from the look she imagined crossed his shadowed face and the hold he took of his breath. "What do I want from you?" Mulder parroted with barely disguised incredulity. "What do you want from *me*, Scully?" His voice almost screeched his disbelief at her question, his hands blindly tapping his chest in emphasis. "What is it, Scully? Did I misbehave tonight around your family so much that you ... you were *embarrassed*? Did I eat with the wrong fork? Hold my coffee cup at the wrong angle? Ask the wrong questions? Talk about the wrong subjects? Or was it just that I was *there*?" 'Truth hurts,' she reminded herself. 'Bear it.' "Is that it, Scully?" He continued his barrage. "Was it just the fact I wanted to be with you and around your family on a holiday, rather than holed up in my hovel of an apartment eating cold pizza and watching reruns of bad porno flicks? What is it, Scully? I'm not *allowed* to enjoy my holiday? I'm not supposed to have something normal and pleasant in my screwed up life?" Mulder's voice began to tighten around the lump in his throat, breaking on his words, quieting as he fired his last salvo at her. "I'm not supposed to have family times, Christmas carols, laughter because I'm *Mulder* -- that sulky guy from the office always in a black mood. Is that it, Scully? I'm not good enough for that? For you?" He turned away from her, his eyes shifting back to the Bay, as he tried to regain his breath and calm his heartache. He prayed fervently the tears he felt stinging his eyes would remain within their limited confines. Damned things! Always wont to escape at the most inopportune moments. Scully bit her lip, forcing her own tears down as she watched him, his back straight in the night, a cold harbinger of the bleakness she imagined she'd face if this man were ever to disappear from her life. She knew if she pushed and kicked long enough, she'd finally break that backbone and force Mulder to leave, and emptiness would fill the void. "You were ... nice," Scully revealed quietly, blinking rapidly as the tears she fought to hold in check filled her eyes. Mulder spun on her, his head cocking slowly, incredulous he heard such a mundane explanation. "Nice?" He repeated, his breath still steaming in pants. "Nice? And I'm ... what? ... not supposed to be? I can be nice. I always thought I was rather a nice guy ... even if I continue to finish last." He tried for his own brand of humor, its joviality feigned and too weak to fill the void he felt crashing in his chest. "Nice?" He narrowed his eyes as he took in the shadow of her face, her eyes glistening with tears. "Is that too much for you?" Mulder asked quietly, sardonic. "You don't think I'm nice? Is that something so ... so *rare* from me you can't handle it? It doesn't fit in with your conception of Fox Mulder?" "No," Scully choked as the tears spilled down her face, shaking her head. Scully hated it when she cried, even in front of Mulder, even though he had been the only one to see her tears in so many years. "No?" She silenced a sniffle, drawing breath through her mouth to respond. "No ... I didn't mean it like that, ... Mulder." Her voice was barely audible over the lap of the water on the shore, her hands stuffed deep into the pockets of her overcoat, her fists tight as her nails dug into her palms. Nothing ... nothing in her arsenal would refocus the pain and anguish, keep the tears at bay. Months of tension and distance between the partners flared, culminating in a chilly evening at the shore of the Chesapeake Bay on Thanksgiving night with snow hanging pregnant in the air. Even though they stood barely three feet apart, Scully felt as if a cavernous gulf lay between them. "You *are* nice," she reaffirmed. "To me ... to my family. The kids loved you. I-I just wasn't ... uhh ... ready for that ... ready to see you so relaxed around them. They ... they loved you ... tonight." The one conclusion rippled through Mulder's mind like concentric rings in a still pond disturbed by the jettison of a skipped stone, sinking light lead at the end of its too short flight.. 'And you ... didn't ... don't.' The silence stretched between them, widening the canyon. The pebble in her throat made breathing difficult, its grip on Scully's chest ached. Mulder stared at her, his face dark and clouded, focused on the pain he saw in her eyes. There was more, something deeper which she was trying to hide. Something which perhaps she had been hiding for years now. The vulnerability was closer to the surface tonight more than ever. As much as he hated the thought, Mulder knew if he didn't exploit the situation, Scully would clam up again, perhaps more fully, more resolutely than before. Mulder took a deep breath, relaxing his hands which had balled on his hips and letting his arms dangle at his side. "What, Scully?" He asked quietly. "What is it? What hurts so much? What is it about me being around your family which hurts you like this? You see your sister -- or her absence -- when I'm there? You *finally* see I'm the cause of that, even though you don't want to admit it to yourself? You see the children I've taken away from you? The family you will never have? And I'm right there in the middle of all that ... that happiness ... a ... a black hole which sucks it right out of a joy-filled room ...?" It wasn't a question, she knew. How could he look into her so deeply to see the things inside she didn't wish to examine? Things she strove to keep under lock and key? "No," she whispered hoarsely, closing her eyes and letting the tears spill down her cheeks unchecked as she lowered her head. "Not that. Never that." "Then what?" Mulder's voice matched hers in timbre. The shakiness of her words was not lost on him, knowing it belied a certain measure of truth. Mulder took a step toward her, resting his hands lightly on her shoulders, trapping her in the spot on the shore, forcing a response. "Tell me, Scully," he beseeched softly. "Please." Scully closed her eyes tightly, placing him out of sight. If she just talked to the air, he wouldn't hear. Right? If she just spoke the words, she'd feel better. It would be out there, hanging suspended in the thick atmosphere of tension surrounding them. With its announcement she would be admitting ... *everything*. Every emotion. Every long held desire. Every tender touch. Every vulnerability. Every need ... of him ... to him. And she would become another grain of sand on this shore, crumpled and broken and lost. Nothing left inside her. Nothing left of her. To blow away with the first staunch wind which came along. To be scraped off the bottom of someone's shoe -- *his* shoe -- when he no longer needed her in his life. He had brought her to this, this final debasement of Dana Scully. There was no woman, no agent, no person left. Just a worn, battered, tired shell. Maybe it was time for Mulder to know what Mulder had done. Not taken away her sister. Not carved up her life and body, but her soul as well. Maybe he should know there was nothing left but the shell, for that was all Scully felt as she stood before him. A shell she fought to maintain for years. And for what reason, she asked herself. To die here? To be left barren and unused ... unwanted ... undesired by the one man she desired? If there was to be pain, why not make it his as well? "I can never give you that," Scully murmured hushed and weak. There, the truth was out, her heart opened to the final assault. Could she make the denouement complete? Could she admit to him she could never give him that joy, that family, that it could never be the two of them together? Some dreams were not meant to come true. A crease appeared in Mulder's forehead. "You can never give me that? What ... what are you ... saying?" "I-I look at you ... like you were tonight -- playing and laughing and having fun, and ... and enjoying the children -- and I know you should have that in your life. You would be a great father, Mulder. And ... and I know I would ... I have lost you ... because ... because I could never give you that." Scully ended on a gossamer's breath of a whisper, her eyes downcast, too unsure of what she would see if she raised her head. In his years at the Bureau people had admired Mulder his eidetic memory for its ability to record and recall, his analytical skills for profiling. But to Fox Mulder, it was his hearing which he secretly appreciated. Acute and keen. Unforgiving most of the time. On occasion he would be angered by what his ears picked up: comments not meant for his notice, slights and barbs to which he was not supposed to be privy, biting comments about the woman he loved. On the shore of the Chesapeake Bay, Fox Mulder found his hearing aciculate beyond belief, as his heart soared in a blue, blue sky, dipping and spinning with disbelief and surprise. His breath caught somewhere around twelve thousand feet, and his heart raced outpacing the best at the Indy. He gasped at her disclosure. "Scully," Mulder sighed tremulously as he slowly drew her into his embrace, lowering his face into her hair. He closed his eyes as if in benediction. What grace had showered upon him in the black of this park? What unannounced wonder had crept into his life, still and strong and sure in the form of the woman he held to his chest? He felt like laughing and crying and whooping for joy all at once, knowing such a reaction would be inexcusable in the gravity of the moment. His hand came up to cup the back of her head, keeping Scully pressed to him. Somewhere he felt her fingers slide up his back, clawing at his jacket, anchoring and securing her to him. Her shoulders shuddered under his arm, and he knew she was weeping quietly. "Oh, Scully," Mulder sighed again, placing a small kiss in her hair, tightening his arm more fully around her. He drew back only so far as necessary to cup her face in his large hands. Even in the dark Mulder could see the slump of her shoulders, feel the weightiness of her head as if every strength within her drained out, his hands the only thing holding her steady. "Scully," he whispered. "Is that what you want? What you've wanted? Us? To be ... ?" He left the question unuttered, its subject foreign and unprecedented on his tongue. Mulder slid his arms back around and drew Scully to him again. "Goddamn, woman!" He chuckled softly, rocking her gently. "Why didn't you *say* something?" Anger surged in her. Scully felt indignation rise, slowly boiling forth from an unrecognized pit deep inside. She struggled to free herself from Mulder's arms, a fire lighting her eyes. But just as quickly as the ire came, it flew. Decorum warred with a chilled stoicism. This was not her. This was not Mulder. Together? Them? She shrugged off the thought, pleasant as it may have once seemed. She could not let him believe there was even this one area of weakness in her. "No," Scully shrugged, rolling her shoulders as Mulder's hands slipped from them. "No," she started again. "That's not--" "No!" Mulder barked, bracing one of her shoulders with his palm, his free hand coming up to shake at her. "Don't, Scully! Don't you dare ... ," he glared at her as he bent to bring his face to her down turned one. "Don't you deny this!" Mulder turned in his stead, grabbed her hand tightly and drew her after him toward the closest picnic table. His motion was sudden and caught her off guard, causing Scully to stumble after him the few paces it took to cross the grass. Stopping at the end of the table, Mulder pulled Scully to the front and hoisted her to sit on the table top. The new position brought their eyes level. Bracing his hands on either side of her hips Mulder leaned in, reclaiming her personal space. "Don't you deny this, Scully," he admonished, beginning gruffly but ending on a gentle and exasperated exhalation. "Please ... not this." Scully's eyes remained wide in shock at his actions. She was sure her heart would pound its way from her chest, no longer needing Padgett's nemesis to help in its extraction. Mulder straightened and stepped closer, until his legs brushed hers and her knees struck his stomach. He dropped his eyes, seemingly mesmerized by the track of his hands as they stroked her forearms. "Scully," he began, his voice hushed, his heart thumping wildly. "Dana," he amended quietly, tasting the word and finding it intimately agreeable. "I-I'm sorry if I brought those memories to you." There, start with the obvious, a topic further from that which loomed around them. "I-I've...." Mulder swallowed, trying to decide where to begin a discourse so foreign to him, yet one he'd conducted mentally for years. "I told you once that I loved you ... in the hospital ... after that time on the Queen Anne." He shrugged his shoulder, hoping the effort would appear nonchalant and she would remember one of his many apparitions she had chosen over the years to ignore.. "I did ... I *do*. I meant it then, even if you didn't believe me." For the first time in his little speech Mulder looked up to her face, to her eyes, seeking acceptance. Scully's eyes were wide, her cheeks tearstained. Her mouth hung open as her head cocked slightly to the side. Her breath was ragged as it caressed his face with a warmth unnatural in late November. "I never ... ," Mulder attempted again, swallowing hard. "I never had much hope there ever could be an 'us'. Is that what worries you? That I wouldn't want you ... barren?" Scully drew a quick breath, then swallowed, but did not respond. This conversation was going from strange to bizarre to a nether world all its own. Mulder looked at her quizzically, awaiting her answer. "Scully?" Slowly Dana Scully nodded her head, still unsure what was happening between them, even if her action was an admission. After years of trying, she could no longer deny Fox Mulder one iota of truth, no matter what it cost her. Mulder's face softened, his eyes luminescent with his own unshed tears. "Oh, Scully," he exhaled, shaking his head. "No. Never. That would never stand in my way." "Then what ... has?" Scully was as surprised as he that she found her voice, even if it was to query such an untenable question. Mulder chuffed awkwardly, his eyes growing wide as he cocked his head at her. "Scul-lee," he droned in exasperation. "You know ... what ... has. Us ... our partnership ... the Bureau ... the ... work." Her eyes skittered away from him, unable to watch him falter any longer, beginning to feel the weight of failure press on her shoulders. For years Scully too used these excuses to keep her feelings for Mulder at bay, but more and more found them lacking in substance if not also in veracity. "The truth, Mulder," she beseeched. He hesitated, lowering his eyes against the piercing stare she fixed upon him. "I didn't think you wanted this," he admitted quietly to his fingernail, it becoming somehow fascinating to him in the black of night where it scratched at the rough plank of the table beside her hip. "I mean, who would want a fuck up like me? Bad luck, bad life, bad karma and all that. You have so much more going for you and you deserve so much better." It was Scully's turn to chuff at his self-deprecation. She rolled her eyes and let out a sigh. Mulder could be so ... Mulder! "If I believed that, Mulder, there would be someone else ... there. Someone at home waiting for me. Someone else going to my mother's for Thanksgiving dinner. The only thing 'bad' we have going for us is timing. Always bad timing." She stopped and considered her words carefully, her voiced falling to a hushed hesitancy. "I-I *do* want this ... *us*. Have for a long time," Scully shrugged. "But I can't give you happiness. I can't give you a family, and you're so good with kids. You belong in a place with kids, with someone who could give you children ... the childhood you never had. I'm not *she*. I can't give you that ... what you saw tonight ... as much as I want to." Mulder shook his head slowly, releasing a scornful sigh. "You and I must have different definitions of 'happiness'. I don't need that. I don't need holidays and family dinners on every occasion possible to be *happy*, Scully. This little conversation we're having tonight will go a long way in that arena ... for years." He stepped closer, between her relaxed legs and settled his hands on her waist. As he sombered his voice dropping to a whisper. "I love you, Scully. You alone make me happy. Having you in my life the little I do is enough to shower me with joy. Don't you know that?" A tear trickled down Scully's cheek as she watched the man before her, head bowed and voice shaky. "I *love* you," he repeated in the quaver of his breath, as if surprised by his own enunciation of a truth long resisted. "Mulder," Scully expelled, mesmerized by the beat of the pulse in his neck, matching her own measure for measure. Her chin trembled and she knew she could not hold back the onslaught of tears for long. In the chilled air she reached her hands for him, grabbing onto his lapels and pulling him toward her so she could slide her arms up his shoulders and around his neck. Mulder's hands gripped her waist, one moving slowly to the middle of her back, drawing her closer to him. She closed her eyes and let the tears fall, bathing his neck with their moisture. As she inhaled, Scully let the dam of her resistance crack, weaken, breached by years of denial and sorrows until it overflowed, exiting her body in wracking, undulating sobs. Mulder held on tightly, her small body trembling with each expulsion, her keening muffled in his jacket. Where her cries that night on his floor after Padgett's creation attacked were in relief for her denial of death and its accompanying fears, tonight her sobs were the release she'd long held in check, tears for the loss of her life as it could have been, and the years of denial of the happiness of which Mulder spoke. He held her, stroking her hair, rocking lightly. In time Scully quieted, taking deep, gulping breaths of crisp air as her head lay against Mulder's shoulder. Her grip around his neck did not slacken, nor did his on her. Scully brushed the tears from her cheeks vainly when she lifted her head. Reaching into his back pocket, Mulder produced a folded handkerchief. "Let me do that," he said tenderly, wiping at the moisture which clung to her chin. "Tonight, Mulder," she said with a watery half-voice. "Tonight at the dinner table when we were going around and saying what we were thankful for, I.... I'm thankful for having you in my life. Thank you for being my friend." Mulder leaned down and brushed his lips lightly across hers. "You're welcome," he mumbled at the corner of her mouth. As he withdrew Scully caught him around the back of his neck, her fingers slipping among his silky hairs and drawing him back. Her lips slid hesitantly over his, one way ... then returning to the other. Mulder's hands reached up to steady her head, holding her still as their lips met a third time, their kiss lingering and chaste. "Scully," he sighed as he withdrew, and rested his forehead against hers. In the bleak winter night their eyes locked, passion and affection flaring deep from within. He cleared his throat as his hands dropped to her shoulders. "Miss Scully, may I have the honor of seeing you home?" Scully expelled a deep sigh, considering her options. "Mulder," she replied in time. Feeling his arm tense, she continued, her voice lowered. "Will you stay ... stay with me ... tonight?" She watched the astonishment settled wide on his face. Nervousness fluttered in her chest. "Please? I.... You're what makes me happy ... and I don't want to say 'good-bye' to that ... 'good-night' ... not tonight ... not ever ... if you want this broken woman." Mulder shook his head sadly. "Oh, Scully. You're not broken ... not in my eyes. And it would be my honor ... my pleasure ... to accompany you anywhere, any time, any place you wish." "Even to ... bed?" "Even to bed ... especially to bed," he chuckled. Stepping back he extended his hand to her. With Scully's fingers wrapped in his, she slid off the picnic table and settled an arm around his waist. Mulder's palm came to rest across her shoulder, drawing her into the shelter of his side. They turned toward the car, for the first time noticing the large sloppy flakes drifting slowly from the sky to land on the carpet of white at their feet. *** the end