From: "Jessica Griffin" Date: Thu, 23 Dec 1999 14:00:06 -0700 Subject: Story Submission Source: direct Title: What I Know Now Author: Jess13 (e-mail jess13@worldnet.att.net) Classification: Alternate Universe, MSR Disclaimer: They are not mine. They are property of CC. (Good thing, eh? Look what I do to them when I borrow them for non-profit fun) Summary: Just why was Scully so smiley to CSM in the pilot? Author's Note: This is my first attempt at writing a fanfiction. It was all written in one sitting when I was suffering from insomnia. I had read some stories about Scully being in the Consortium but they never really give a reason why she would do it. So, I wanted to come up with a reason why and then see how many of the events in the series could have really happened if she was in league with the CSM. I tried to be as accurate with dates as possible (looked them up on the timeline). I'd say this story takes place in Season Five without Emily having happened yet. CSM is till presumed dead. So, bear with me and any feed back would be great. Thank you! PART 1 Mulder's Apartment Present Day 9:13pm I've never been so afraid in my life. Not even when I was looking death in the face as cancer ravaged my body. Now, I'm looking death in the face once more. It is not as predictable as the cancer was. I remember thinking that cancer is like an intruder that takes over your body. The only way to destroy is to risk destroying yourself. I wonder if that is how he thinks of me- as a cancer that infected his life years ago that he has just realized will end up killing him. His eyes are nearly unrecognizable. They are more flat and dark then I can ever remember seeing them. No matter how awful our fights were in the past, he always let some vestige of adoration leak through his resolve. Now he just stares. "How could you do this to me?" He asks, breaking the deadly silence. I thought nothing could terrify me more than the electric silence between us. I was wrong. Every carefully calculated word stabs a new wound into my heart and I know that I deserve nothing less. I have no idea how to answer him. He rises from his black leather couch and begins to pace the floor in front of the chair I am seated in at his desk. Thankfully, the eye contact that he held me captive with is broken. "Come on, Scully. You never had any problem talking before. I asked you a question." He stops pacing and draws near to me. I let my head lower until my chin grazes my chest. I fight not to let the tears spring from my eyes. I hear rather then see him stop right in front of me and feel his hand cup my chin to look into my face. "You look at me and tell me. Was it fun to play with Old Spooky in the basement? That's all this was for you right, Scully? A fucking game?" I would have felt better if he was yelling at me. Rather, his voice rumbles in a low calculated voice. "No." I say in less than a whisper meeting his gaze head on. He lets out a humorless laugh. "No?" He repeats incredulously as he brings his other hand up to cup my face. In other circumstances, a touch like this would represent the longing that we had to make our relationship more than it was. But in this case, he is using to hurt me. He is showing me what will never be because of my deception. "Then what was it to you, Scully?" "Mulder..." I begin and falter. "I don't... I don't know how to make you understand this all..." This makes him angry. His hands remain on my face and I feel the dampness of his palms on my cheeks as he tightens his hold on me. "Make me understand what, Scully? I think that if you had any intention of ever making me understand anything you would have volunteered it, not let me find out through the Gunmen about your secret rendezvous with that black-lunged son of a bitch!" Now he is shouting. I was wrong to think it would be better if he were shouting. "I didn't know in the beginning, Mulder!" I shout back. "I had no clue about anything to do with the X-Files or colonization! I was lied to from the beginning! I thought I was helping! By the time I knew what was really going on I was in too deep. By the time I figured out I was on the wrong side I couldn't switch without something happening to you!" His hands finally move from my face. The only noise in the apartment is sound of his fish tank's air filter humming and our ragged, post-shouting breath. "You expect me to believe that? You expect me to believe anything you ever say again?" "No, Mulder, I don't. But just listen to what I have to say. Please." He sits back down on the couch resigned. He runs a hand through his hair and then looks at me expectantly. "Fine." PART 2 University of Maryland April 3, 1990 1:59pm "Ms. Scully!" A man I don't recognize jogs up next to me as I walk across the quad after my Graduate level Physics class. I stop and look at him questioningly. He is slightly beyond middle aged and smells of a mix of sandlewood and tobacco. He extends his hand and I take it somewhat reluctantly and shake it. "I'm very pleased to finally speak to you in person, Ms. Scully." I take back my hand and he reaches for a cigarette. He gestures to me asking if I'd like one as well. "No, thank you. May I ask how you know me? Have we met?" He smiles. "No, but you have created quite a name for yourself. If you don't mind me asking, what are you planning on doing with your medical degree?" I feel uncomfortable to say the least but feel compelled to answer nonetheless. My planned career only borders on personal. Now, if he starts asking about my plans to have a family, then out comes the trusty mace. "Um, I'm not sure. I have some interest forensic pathology. Maybe I will work in a Medical Examiner's office." I begin to walk again slowly. The stranger follows me. "Pathology, huh? Seems a little dreary for such a pretty young woman." I stop and give him a cursory glance. "Who exactly did you say you were?" I say, thinking about the mace in my pocket. "I didn't say, but if you will indulge me, I think that you may be interested in what I have to talk to you about." He takes a long drag from his cigarette and then tosses it onto the ground. He the steps on it, slowly grounding out the bright orange cherry. "And what exactly is that?" He glances around and then gestures for me to follow him to student union. It seems public enough so I follow him. We sit down in a corner booth and he pulls out another cigarette. "You know those things will kill you, right?" I say. "Doubtful that they will be the end of me." He says with an ironic look on his face. "Now, Ms. Scully. Have you ever considered a job in the government?" "Excuse me?" That is one of the last things I expected to come out of the man's mouth. "For someone of your talent, there are a lot of possibilities for you to succeed in the FBI." I chuckle. "The FBI. I think my father would kill me. He's already not very pleased with my interest in Forensic Medicine. What exactly would I be doing?" He takes a drag of his cigarette and lets the smoke seep out his nostrils reminding me of a dragon. "We have a specific assignment in mind for you. You would make a huge difference. Really distinguish yourself." I have to admit I like the sound of that. I don't speak so he takes that as a tacit clue to continue. "You see, right now there is a classified project dealing with the development of a vaccination that could help a lot of people. Some of the information that is vital to the development of this vaccination lies in the jurisdiction of the bureau. Someone with your expertise would be invaluable in assessing that information and making sure that no one... throws off... the project." My mind began reeling. "Wait a minute, what kind of vaccination? Why haven't I heard of this project?" "I told you, it's classified. Your participation can only help mankind. We need you, Dana." He exhaled another puff of smoke and looked intently right into my eyes. "I don't understand, why me? Why not someone who is already a doctor? There has got to be someone more qualified." He smiles again and my skin crawls involuntarily. "We don't make mistakes, Ms. Scully. You are the most qualified for this mission. Don't doubt your importance." He ends resolutely. He then stands and hands me a slip of paper. "I know you will choose for the benefit of mankind." And with that he disappears leaving behind only that slip of paper and the still smoking butt of his cigarette in the ashtray behind. I unfold the paper carefully and stare at it: WASHINGTON MONUMENT TONIGHT 8PM I almost expect it to say "Be there or be square". The thought makes me smile as I slowly fold the paper up and place it in my pocket. PART 3 ~~ Later ~~ I figure it can't hurt to simply attend this 8 o'clock meeting so here I am walking around the Washington Monument feeling a little more that a bit self conscious until I catch sight of the smoking man once more. I tentatively walk towards him. "Ms. Scully, a very wise choice. I knew you would do the right thing." "Wait a minute, I haven't made any choice, I just need more information." He looks at me with an amused expression. "Come with me." Against my better judgment, I follow him to a black Buick and get inside. He guides the car away from the curb and navigates the streets. "Ms. Scully... Dana... it is absolutely imperative that you make a commitment to the project immediately. Time and lives are wasting away." "Whoa, not so fast. How can you expect me to commit to something that I know nothing about? The only assurance I have that it is the right decision comes from a lone man that I don't even know who talks in nebulous generalizations about the benefit of mankind." He pulls out a cigarette and lights it without taking his eyes off of the road. I cough as he expels smoke and I crack my window open. "I wouldn't expect anything less from you, Dana. All will be explained in time. First, I need a guarantee that what you learn about the project during this decision making step will not be repeated to anyone. Understood?" I nod despite myself. He pulls the car over to the side of the road. "The disease that we are attempting to create a vaccination for has a very small incubation period. The FBI investigates the cases surrounding this disease only on the surface. The truth is, they don't have anyone qualified enough to be able to recognize the disease. Unfortunately, in their ignorance, they have labeled these mysterious deaths as unsolved which only slowed us down before. However, now, there is a man fighting to open these unsolved cases and it is only a matter of time before he stumbles across this disease and inadvertently infects the entire population or at the very least creates a panic that could lead to the break down of the government. We need you to come in and provide a check to this man. He is very intelligent, but a loose cannon. There is nothing more dangerous than misdirected intelligence. Open the glove compartment." I do so and pull out a personnel folder labeled "Special Agent Fox William Mulder" I flip through a few of the pages. "So this is the man you are so afraid of." "Do not make light of this situation, Ms. Scully. This man is more dangerous than he knows." "So, you want me to come in and stop him? How am I supposed to do that?" I flip to a picture of the Agent Mulder. Not bad, not bad at all. "You are going to be assigned to work with him following the completion of your training. It will be your job to keep track of him and make sure that he never causes a public panic. Also, you need to filter the research to the project so we can develop the vaccine." We sit in silence for a few moments. And for some reason, this all feels right. "Are you with the FBI? How can you be sure that I'll be assigned to work with him?" He chuckles. "No, I'm not with the FBI, but it will be no problem to get you assigned. The project is very... influential." And I know what I have to decide. PART 4 J. Edgar Hoover Building March 7, 1992 "Agent Scully, thank you for coming on such short notice." I sit down opposite of Section Chief Blevins as he asks me about whether I've heard of Fox Mulder. I notice the man who started me on this path leaning against a filing cabinet with the everpresent Morely in his hand. I glance at him as I say I gave up my career in medicine to distinguish myself. I throw him a knowing smile as I describe Agent Mulder as "Spooky" as I was instructed. The familiar figure doesn't smile back. He just watches to make sure that I am assigned to the X-Files as we planned. As Blevins instructs me to make contact with Agent Mulder as soon as possible I feel a smile creep up on my face in triumph. This isn't so hard after all. I walk straight out of the room and head straight for the basement to meet my fate. I knock suddenly feeling a little tentative. "Sorry, nobody here but the FBI's most unwanted." I take that as an invitation to enter. I am taken aback by the spectacled man in front of me. The personnel picture did not do him justice. I extend my hand and introduce myself. "Well isn't is nice to be suddenly so highly regarded? Who'd you piss off to get stuck with this detail, Scully?" I suddenly feel uneasy under his gaze. This is going to be harder than I thought. He is so suspicious of me already. But, I didn't spend fifteen weeks in training and two years teaching in the bowels of Quantico to have this man, the whole purpose of me joining the FBI, scare me away in the first five minutes. "Actually, I was looking forward to working with you. I've heard a lot about you" I manage to get out smoothly. "Really? Because I was under the impression that you were sent to spy on me." Oh shit. I pray that my face didn't go as white as my soul just did. No, he will not scare me away. I just need to convince him I'm an innocent, green field agent. "If you have any doubts about my qualifications or credentials..." The conversation continues and I gain a small triumph. This man didn't think I would still be here this far into to the conversation. So he tries a new approach. "Do you believe in the existence of extraterrestrials?" He says in a patronizing voice. A role defining moment. "Logically, I would have to say no given the distances needed to travel from the far reaches of space..." and continue on the stance hat it was agreed that I should take in order to debunk this man's work. And so my deception begins. But little did I know it was me that I was deceiving. PART 5 Mulder's Apartment Present Day Mulder just sits. He hasn't interrupted my story once. He just watches me and I can tell that he is trying to decide if I am telling him the truth. The question hangs in the air between us so I do what we never did before. I answered the unspoken words that we communicate. "Mulder, I don't have any reason to lie to you now. The way I see it, you have decided that we are through. I'm just clearing the air now. Not just for you, but for me too." He looks at me and his eyes soften for a moment. Then they steel back up. "What about you abduction Scully? And your cancer? None of that was real? Do you know what that did to me?" "Mulder, please, let me explain. I'm going to get to that. First, I have some more back story that you aren't going to like. "What more could you tell me about?" He asked me. I took a deep breath. "What really happened to Deep Throat." Against his will, his mouth dropped open. "You see, you and I were having a great solve rate on cases that didn't have anything to do with the black cancer. At first, it was thought by the smoker that I was slipping in my influence and actually making you a better investigator. In reality, you ended up telling me about Deep Throat and I told the smoker. For that I am so sorry about. Deep Throat didn't know that I was working for the Project. He was on a need-to-know basis just like me only he had been around a lot longer. He got me into that facility to steal the fetus so we could get you back, Mulder. I don't think he knew about me at that point. He trusted me." I pause to assess Mulder's reaction to what I'm saying. He isn't looking at me, he is only staring straight ahead. "Mulder, what I realized too late was that this was a good man in bad circumstances, just like I was only he was aware of it and I wasn't. When it came time to make the exchange I wanted to do it because I knew the men who had you. But, he insisted that he do it because he was secure that the men didn't know he was the mole." My voice cracks involuntarily which catches Mulder's attention. My shoulders shake as I try to control my emotions. Mulder's face registers pity for me for the first time tonight it is more than I can bare. "He was shot because I told that he was helping you, Mulder. It was all my fault and Deep Throat knew it in the end. As he lay dying he said 'Trust no one' to me. To me and at me!" Tears run freely down my face now. Mulder just sits and looks at me with a softened expression. An expression I don't deserve but want to embrace more than anything. I reach for a tissue and unceremoniously blow my nose. "Anyway," I continue "after Deep Throat died the smoker made contact with me. He told me that I had allowed you to get too close to the truth and that our partnership was to be dissolved. I felt like a failure. I wasn't helping anyone by being in the bureau and I was just beginning to see what I fool I was to believe that you were the bad guy. It was only after we were separated that I realized just how corrupt the Project was. That's why I tracked you down in Puerto Rico." I took a deep breath and continued. "And I paid dearly for that action. I was told to stay away from you. But, you kept coming to consult with me and I couldn't turn you away. Even after they assigned Kryceck as your partner you still came to me. I didn't know Kryceck was part of the Project at the time. I know now he served a dual purpose. First was to do the job I was supposed to do- debunk you. Only he was to come from the direction of a believer in your work. The second purpose was to watch your interaction with me. And, he found out we were still communicating. To punish me, they cooked up the whole Duane Barry abduction which at the time was very real for me. The thing is, not all of what happened to me had been suppressed. I remember most of it though I wish I didn't. I don't remember them taking my ova or implanting the chip. They abducted me to scare me, Mulder. To stop me from siding with you anymore. They nearly killed me to do this. But I guess I deserved it." He turns sharply towards me. "Scully-" "Please Mulder, let me go on. I know that your informant X knew about my involvement in the Project. That's why he tried to convince you not to dig about what happened to me. He figured you would find out the truth about me and that it would break your resolve." "If this is true the why were you reassigned to work with me, Scully? It doesn't make any sense." "Because the abduction was supposed to make me realize that I had to support the project. They threatened that if I didn't that they would harm my family or you. And I couldn't take that. So, I cooperated to the best of my ability all the while trying not to betray you. But then, you started acting strange towards me and I started to wonder why I was trying to protect you at all." His expression changed to quizzical. "What do you mean, I was acting strange?" "Do the names Bambi and Detective White ring a bell with you? I couldn't figure out why you would purposely flaunt the fact that you could have a sexual conquest any time you wanted in my face." I said that a little more bitterly than I intended to. "I did not flaunt anything in your face! I'm allowed to look at other women even if I-" He caught himself. "Anyway, it's not important Mulder. Anyway, this chasm between us started to open up and I became lost. It made it so much easy to carry out the Project's agenda and misdirect you. However, anytime I'd ask the smoker about when I would be able to assist with the vaccine he would remind me that I was not to speak of that and that I was on a need to know basis. Then, I learned that they had taken a step without letting me know. After you got the DAT tape I didn't tell the smoker you had it. I lied to him. I lied to Skinner who I know was manipulated by the smoker. I protected you and you threw it in my face calling me spy. I couldn't get angry. Besides the fact you were grieving over your murdered father, which I swear to you I don't know the truth about, and you were drugged, I also knew you were right not to trust me in every case except this one where I drew a clear line of loyalties to you. That is until they made an attempt on my life and killed my sister instead." A tear slipped by my newly acquired control as I let a moment pass for Melissa. It just wasn't fair. Missy had nothing to do with my mess but she dies for it. How meaningless is that? Mulder stood up and place his hand on my forearm. I glanced up from my feet and made eye contact with him. Incredibly, he held his arms out to me and I accepted them crying softly into his shoulder for him, for me, and all of those that suffered because of my foolishness. For a moment, the rest of the world faded away and only he and I were left together. I knew that the one truth that was my constant was that I am in love with this man who I have no claim to because of my lies. "Mulder, please, let me finish my story before you decide if you really want to touch me." "Scully, you've been telling me the truth, you didn't ever want to hurt me." "Damn it Mulder, yes I did!" He released me and sat back down, ready to listen. PART 6 "When Melissa died and you just wanted to move on with life as usual, I wanted to hate you so bad. I even started to. I had risked and lost nearly everything for you and that DAT, Mulder. And you just didn't care." "Yes, I did Scully. I just didn't know how to act." "It doesn't matter now anyway, Mulder. I resented you because it was because of you that I was in this mess in the first place. The smoker had plucked me out of my normal life where I would work as a medical examiner or even have my own practice. A world where I could be happily married with a child by now. He chose me because he thought I could bring you down subversively without even realizing that was what I was doing. So, you see, I resented you quite a bit. You had unknowingly changed my whole existence and then went along like it was no big deal. I didn't see where you were trying to acclimate to me at all. Hell you couldn't even get me a fucking nameplate. One fucking nameplate, Mulder!" "Scully-" He started, probably to defend the nameplate thing. "I don't care about the goddamn name plate anymore, Mulder. What all of that made me do though was to actively try to sabotage you, not that it ever worked. You'd never listen to me anyway." She gave him a wry smile. "However, the although you were oblivious to my sabotage, the smoker was not. It angered him because he and the others had developed a new agenda for you. You were to debunk yourself and I would be used for that detail against my will. Thus, I was given cancer." PART 7 "You see, Kritsgau was right when they said that they gave me my cancer to make you believe. What he didn't know was the cancer was also a punishment for me because I was not fulfilling my responsibility. And in Allentown, I had resigned my fate. My foolish choice in medschool would be my end. I started to write all of this for you in my journal in Allentown. Thank God you didn't read that far. I kept waiting for you to say that you learned I was a traitor from the beginning, but it never came. It was after Penny died that you convinced me to live. And I finally admitted to myself that I was in love with you." His eyes widened at that statement. "Scully I" I held up my hand to silence him. Now was not the time for admissions of love. I had to finish first. "The smoker was less than ecstatic when he realized the cancer wasn't slowing me down and that it brought us closer together. So, he arranged a meeting between the two of us that I now believe was designed for the Gunmen to discover. I know they knew about it but I don't know why they didn't tell you about it right then. Why they waited until now. He told me that if I was loyal to the Project again my life would be spared. I told him that I didn't care. So, he said that if I played my role you would be safe. He said my role was to point out Skinner as the mole to make you not trust him. So, to keep you safe, I almost did the unforgivable. I almost destroyed a man." Somehow saying these things makes them seem so much worse. "Do you remember when Father McCue came and saw me? I told him everything. He said God would forgive me but one has to question the truth of words that are designed to comfort the dying. I felt my chance of redemption was to have everything blamed on me. It was nearly true anyway. Do you know how bad I felt when you wouldn't even let me save you after I had gotten you into this mess?" "I couldn't let you take the blame for killing that man. It turns out to be something that you were blameless for. Scully, I don't understand why you couldn't just tell me all of this? Did you have that little faith in me that you thought I wouldn't understand?" He didn't sound angry, he just sounds tired. "Mulder, maybe you can explain something to me." He looked at me inquisitively. "How did you get the cure for my cancer? It's obvious that the smoker let you have it." "It was all a bribe Scully. He was trying to get me to join the Project. Part of that agenda was to let you live as a gift from him. But I saw through it Scully. The only way he could have a cure for you cancer was if he had caused it in the first place. So, I used him to let you live and said no deal. He told me it was noble to be a part of the Project and that I would be surprised who had been assisting him over the years. I told him nothing surprised me anymore. That's when I first suspected you, Scully. For once, I didn't want to believe." "That explains the last meeting he and I had. He came to the hospital after the chip was implanted and told me that he was wrong- the Project did make mistakes and I was proof. He also hinted that you would find out about me and that you wouldn't trust me again. I said I could LIVE with that as long as you were okay. He told me that I would live but never be complete. And I knew he was right." "After you were recovered from the cancer I went to the Gunmen and that is when they told me about your meetings. Scully, I've never felt so betrayed in my life." "I'm so sorry Mulder. I really did get involved in the first place thinking that I was doing the right thing." He looked at me and all of the walls that we had been building crumbled down around us. "I know that now, Scully." He said as he pulled me towards him and wrapped his arms around him. PART 8 His face nuzzled into my hair and I felt a tremor go through me body as my resolve melted away. We stood there in silence with tears streaming down our faces. We were like two soldiers that had survived the battle physically unscathed but had enough emotional wounds to overwhelm a triage. I felt his lips press into my scalp and I tightened my embrace around him. Now, he knew all of my demons. "Did you mean what you said earlier, Scully?" "I meant all of it. Which part do you mean?" I felt him smile against my forehead as he leaned down to kiss it. "I'm in love with you, too." He cupped my face in his hands as he had done earlier only this time there were no accusations, only gentle acceptance. I met his lips halfway and we shared a kiss. I can taste the salt of his tears on his lips and I push away the feelings of shame that I'm the reason for his tears. With what I know now, I wish I could go back and be his partner with a clean slate. He deserved so much more than what he got from me and I'll be sorry about that forever. "Scully" He said after we parted lips. "Yes?" My voice registered just above a whisper. "I think too much has happened here." My heart falls to my feet and I step out of his embrace. "Where are you going?" "You're right Mulder, too much has happened for being together to be the right thing for us." "That's not what I meant." My heart picks up a little. "What did you mean?" "Just that maybe we've seen enough of the bureau. I have other connections to investigate. You've never had anything keeping you at the bureau. What's stopping you from a private practice or working as a medical examiner?" "I just never wanted to leave you." I say. It feels odd to be able to finally say what's on my mind. "Then let's just go together. Everything will work out just fine." And for once I want to believe. EPILOGUE: Mulder's voice filled the room as it was broadcast from the bug in his apartment. "Then let's just go together." Good, the man thought, I knew Scully would finally come through. I told her we don't make mistakes. He slowly pulled out a Morely and lit it up, taking in a deep, self-satisfied drag in celebration of the perfect manipulation. THE END